Proper Pie Co.

Elizabeth Wright 2 months ago

I only managed to snap a picture of the sausage roll before everything was devoured 😍 I'll add pics of the sweet pies before we eat them. We ordered the butter chicken (AMAZING!), sausage roll, mince and cheese, steak and cheese, and pork/apple/cheddar for savory pies. Key lime, peach melba, and banofee for sweet pies. Love the crust love everything!

Caleb 2 months ago

Recommend to try from a friend. Did NOT disappoint. Best turtle of anything I've ever had. Great key lime, not too tangy. Lemon blueberry is so warm & cozy. They also have savory options. I don't even choose pie for my desserts but these are outstanding. Order at the window. No indoor seating but a few spots are available on the sidewalk.

Food4Thought 5 months ago

My first time trying this and here are my thoughts. This is a local walk up shop that to me puts a new spin on the classic "Pot Pie". Initially I was concerned about portion size and cost/value. The pies seem geared towards a lunch only appeal. At right about 5" wide I was thinking 1 would not be enough. I needed not worry. What they lack in size they more than make up for in both flavor and hardiness. I was actually impressed by the complex flavors and quality of the components. I tried 2 different savory pies and sweet pies to try and get a good idea of quality and consistency. The food hits it out of the park and exceeded expectations. They sell large sweet pies and I think they would do well doing the same for someone to take home & share as a savory dinner choice. The staff and service were exceptional and quickly addressed questions/concerns. The only real negative has nothing to do with the product, price or service. Initial impression from the outside is they seem to have an agenda that could impact their business. I personally feel opinions are for persons not business but it is their right.

Musa Sagnia 7 months ago

Great pies, savory or sweet, make your choice! Both amazing and doesn't breat the bank. In my opinion I always go for the savory pies (salmon ❤️) as the taste is amazing. Get them while supply last! Nice place for locals or visitors to check this Richmond staple!

Carrie Lewis 9 months ago

It is a little old hole in the wall with LOTS of character and Fab food. Now I have had a meet pie, :) but I live for their apple pie. This stuff is the BOMB. It is light and airy and not overly sweet which makes it the perfect treat. I hate when things are SUPER, knock you out, need a insulin pen, cannot eat but a few bites sweet. This pie is NOT that. It is sweet but naturally sweet which makes it amazing.